Neda Semnani,  September 12, 2013

George Packer’s Abstract Period



Leaving a great abstraction untouched is the practice of an investigator who’s already chosen sides, or so suggests Baffler senior editor Chris Lehmann in his review of New Yorker staff writer George Packer’s latest book, The Unwinding.

The review, published Thursday at The Nation online, will be published in the September 30 issue of the Nation magazine.

Packer’s latest tome is the story of America’s economic unraveling over the past few decades. The author uses several characters – from an assembly worker to a Treasury secretary – to paint the broad panoramic sweep of our nation’s recent economic face-palm. Lehmann gives Packer credit for crafting a work of compelling prose and for at least attempting narrative acrobatics that are reminiscent of John Dos Passos’s seminal work of fiction, U.S.A.. However, Packer falls down, in Lehmann’s estimation, by not kicking any sort of critical ass. Packer disappoints by not going out on a limb to name names and lay blame where blame is definitely due, and he does the reader a deep disservice by not rendering, in any real specific detail, the lives of those most affected by our nation’s economic implosion.

Read Lehmann’s review here.


Neda Semnani is a freelance writer. Her work has appeared in The Week, Los Angeles Review of BooksBuzzfeed, and others.

You Might Also Enjoy

The Reaching-Out Industry

Tim Donnelly

A whole new cottage industry has popped up seeking a more earnest, direct conversation, begging Trump voters to sit down and explain: how exactly did we get this way?

word factory

Baffler Newsletter

new email subscribers receive a digital copy of our current issue.

Further Reading

 February 20

Edward Lansdale does not represent the “Road not Taken” in Vietnam, he is the crystallized essence of the willful blindness that led us there.

 February 13

A truly progressive man would be one who rejects the social and economic advantages that come from masculinity, with a “feminine flourish.”